From One Pie to Six: How the Man-Made Pecan Pie Collection Was Built
Before there was a website, before the blue ribbon, and before I started debating the perfect pie crust, there was pecan pie.
PECAN PIE
Michael, the man behind Man-Made Pies
6/22/20262 min read
Like a lot of people, I spent more time baking during the COVID lockdown. What started as a simple goal to make a better pecan pie quickly became an obsession. I tested sweeteners, crusts, baking temperatures, and techniques. Friends, family, neighbors, and coworkers became willing taste-testers. Spreadsheets were created. Notes were taken. More pies were baked than I care to admit.
Eventually, one of those pies earned First Place at the 2024 Maryland State Fair. That recipe became the foundation of everything you'll find in the Man-Made Pies pecan pie collection.
The Philosophy Behind Every Pecan Pie
Every pecan pie on this site follows the same core principles. Instead of relying on corn syrup alone, I wanted a filling with more depth, better balance, and a cleaner finish.
That led me to a few techniques that now appear in every version:
Toast the pecans before they go into the pie.
Use agave syrup for a smoother sweetness.
Build caramel flavor with brown sugar.
Always par-bake the crust.
Bake until the center still has a gentle wobble.
Those ideas became the foundation for every pecan pie I make.
It All Started with One Recipe
Blue Ribbon Classic Pecan Pie
Everything begins here. This is the exact recipe that earned First Place at the Maryland State Fair. If you've never made one of my pies before, this is where I'd start.
Bake the Blue Ribbon Classic Pecan Pie →
Then Came the Bourbon
Once the classic recipe was finished, the next question was simple:
"What happens if I add bourbon?"
The answer surprised me. Rather than dominating the pie, bourbon quietly deepened the caramel notes and made the toasted pecans taste even richer. It quickly became my Thanksgiving favorite.
Then Chocolate Entered the Conversation
The third recipe pushed things even further. Dark chocolate, toasted pecans, and bourbon turned out to be a combination that felt indulgent without losing what makes pecan pie special. It's become my favorite recipe whenever I want something that feels a little more over-the-top.
Bake the Chocolate Bourbon Pecan Pie →
Then I Shrank Them
Not every pie needs to feed eight people. Some of my favorite evenings involve two forks, two plates, and no leftovers. That's why every recipe eventually earned a 6-inch version.
Whether you're baking for date night, a small gathering, or simply don't want a week's worth of leftovers, the smaller pies deliver the same flavors in a more manageable size.
Which Pie Should You Bake?
New to Man-Made Pies: Start with the Blue Ribbon Classic.
Love bourbon: Bake the Bourbon Pecan Pie.
Need a showstopper: Choose the Chocolate Bourbon Pecan Pie.
Baking for two: Go with one of the 6-inch versions.
Where the Collection Goes Next
Even though the collection now includes six recipes, I still come back to the original Blue Ribbon Classic more than any other. It's the recipe that taught me how small changes in ingredients and technique can transform an ordinary pie into something memorable. And if history is any indication, it probably won't be the last pecan pie experiment to come out of my kitchen.
Award-winning pie recipes
Homemade Pie Crusts, Brownies, and Bold Desserts Built From Scratch.
A curated collection of recipes I actually make, trust, and come back to.
Built one pie at a time in Baltimore.
Good pies start with good crust. Everything else is just filling.
Michael@manmadepies.com
© 2025. All rights reserved.